PRL新动态，大家帮忙分析一下 散金60

　　PRL新动态，大家帮忙分析一下 散金60。9月26号PRL（Physical Review Letters），苦苦等待45天后，编辑发来意见：
Dear ***,

The above manuscript has been reviewed by our referee.

A critique drawn from the report appears below. On this basis, we
judge that the paper is not appropriate for Physical Review Letters,
but might be suitable for publication in another journal, possibly
with some revision. Therefore, we recommend that you submit your
manuscript elsewhere.

Yours sincerely,
最初，编辑让三个审稿人审稿，只有一个审稿人在10月3号返回comments。他说我们的实验结果很好，但是解释不够物理。用的理论模型太唯象。其他两个审稿人过了一个多月也没有给回复，编辑就基于这一个审稿人的意见做了上述决定。
投其他，我真的很不甘心。毕竟这个实验做了将近三年。我想再充实一下内容，换一个物理基础较好的模型再试一次。PRL毕竟是一个梦想。现在的状态是：
CURRENT STATUS OF MANUSCRIPT: Not under active consideration

Copyright/Right to Publish received
CORRESPONDENCE:
SENT RECEIVED DESCRIPTION
08Nov11 Editorial decision and/or referee comments sent to author
27Sep11 08Nov11 Review request to referee; editor concludes response unlikely
03Oct11 08Nov11 Review request to referee; editor concludes response unlikely
17Oct11 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals]
11Oct11 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals]
27Sep11 03Oct11 Review request to referee; report received
27Sep11 28Sep11 Review request to referee; message received (not a report)
27Sep11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
27Sep11 Right to publish signature received
27Sep11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
27Sep11 Acknowledgment sent to author
27Sep11 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author

大家帮忙分析一下：Not under active consideration
是什么意思，是被拒了吗？
怎么？
谢谢！

[ Last edited by cxksama on 2011-11-10 at 08:17 ]
===有问必答===
Not under active consideration 就是悲剧了

现在PRL越来越难了

我们组的一篇文章三个审稿人都觉得不错， 但是编辑还是拒了. 理由是他觉得不适合在PRL上发表.

看来PRL真的提高档次了.
----

PRL是物理的顶尖，除了nature和science外的最好的，肯定是很难的，在国内发个一到二篇，在很多高校随便混了
----

我认为就是最好的物理，不是除了nature和science.

我认为这篇文章是没什么戏了。因为在录用和这个决定之间编辑还有一个选择，就是你发表在PR的Rapid Communication上。但是编辑并没有给出。
----
你这情形和我当时的审稿结果一样。我然后转投到PRA上第二天就据稿了，所以你转投PRB吧，但是转投的时候要小心了。
----
我觉得你投PRL的希望很渺茫了。我你退而求其次吧。
----
完全没有希望.编辑都不考虑你的了.我上次投了后两个审稿意见,两个审稿意见算中等,我感觉挺难argue的，虽然当时状态时with authors，还是转到PRB的brief report.你现在投PRB的Rapid Communication比较难
----
Not under active consideration
一般就是悲剧了，改投吧。